Showing posts with label capitalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label capitalism. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Why women have better sex under socialism - Part 2

 This is a review and analysis of the book "Why women have better sex under socialism" to illustrate how economic independence shapes relationships and how capitalism profits from lack of love, affection and connection. 
Jena, Oct. 2026

"Women, Like Men, but Cheaper"


Cover of Why Women Have Better Sex Under Socialism by Kristen R. Ghodsee
One of the oldest ways to keep a woman powerless is also the simplest: never let her control her own money. If a woman can't own property, can't work without permission, can't walk away because she has nowhere else to go, dependence on a man stops being a choice and becomes the whole structure her life is built on. For most of legal history, marriage made this literal, a woman's property, her labor, even her legal identity got absorbed into her husband's. In West Germany, married women legally needed their husband's permission to work outside the home until 1957. This logic survived well into modern capitalist societies, and not just in West Germany. In France, married women couldn't open a bank account or take a job without their husband's permission until 1965. In Switzerland, husbands held formal legal authority over whether their wives could work until a 1988 marital law reform. In Spain under Franco, the permiso marital required a husband's written consent for a wife to sign an employment contract, and it wasn't abolished until 1975. Even in the United States, where no law formally blocked women from working, banks could legally require a husband's signature before issuing a married woman her own credit card until 1974. None of this is distant history, it sits within the lifetime of our own parents or grandparents.

This dependence wasn't unique to Christian Europe, but it also wasn't universal. On property and money, historically, Islamic law was actually ahead of the West by over a thousand years. Classical Islamic law gave married women an independent legal and financial personality from early Islam onward, a wife's property and earnings were legally hers alone, the husband had no claim on her wealth, and she kept her mahr (the money or property paid to her at marriage) as personal property. Western coverture law did the opposite: a married woman's property, wages, and legal identity were absorbed into her husband's, and that didn't start reversing until the Married Women's Property Acts of the late 1800s in the UK and US. 

hat advantage on property didn't carry over everywhere, though. On work, mobility, and guardianship, Islamic law varied enormously by country and era, and some restrictions lasted longer than in the West. Tunisia's 1956 Code of Personal Status was genuinely progressive for the region (banned polygamy, ended a wife's legal "obligation of obedience"), though the explicit right to work and bank without a husband's permission came through later reforms, not the 1956 Code itself. At the other end, Saudi Arabia's male guardianship system required a woman to have a male relative's permission to travel until 2019, and working or opening certain accounts was similarly gated through guardianship. 

Put these pieces side by side and a clearer picture emerges: women's economic dependence on men propagated through economic, civil, and religious institutions alike, although it cannot be denied that it oppressed differently depending on the country, and it was not a rule that Islam equaled oppression while western Christianism equaled freedom. 

Whatever the religious or legal starting point, capitalism inherited this dependence and adapted it efficiently: men tied to wages, women tied to men. Work done inside the home stayed invisible and unpaid, while work done outside it got undervalued simply because a woman was doing it. During industrialization, this had a name, almost a business case: women were hired because they were "like men, but cheaper", just as productive, paid less. At the same time, employers called women unreliable, because women were the ones expected to drop everything for a sick kid or an aging parent. Paid work undervalued, unpaid work assumed, that double force still runs most of the world. It shows up in strange places too: J.K. Rowling and E.L. James published under initials, not because they wanted to, but because a male-coded name still opens doors a female one doesn't. And none of these lands the same way for every woman: race, class, disability, and sexuality stack different weights on top of the same basic structure.

Here's where socialism, actually broke something: it refused to treat women's place in the workforce as optional. Female labor participation across the Soviet bloc sat around 40–50%, compared to roughly 30–37% in the US and much of Western Europe at the time. Women became doctors, engineers, scientists, administrators, not because patriarchy magically disappeared (it didn't; the pay gap and the unpaid second shift stuck around), but because the state made dependence structurally harder to maintain. Public-sector jobs tend to enforce equal pay and equal access more consistently than private ones, simply because hiring and wages answer to public rules instead of a boss's discretion. 

That link between weak states and dependent women isn't just historical. It shows up right now in the current discourse of rising right-wing populist parties of “making the State more efficient by reducing it to its minimal” and “keeping traditional women’s roles”, since a weak State guarantees less women’s rights implementation. A strong public sector isn't charity, it's an engine that creates jobs while expanding the childcare, healthcare, and education that let people actually use them.

Compare that to how capitalism treats its own failures: calling the private sector efficient while quietly saving it from bankrupt whenever it collapses, or funding private universities through student debt that enriches investors more than it educates anyone. "Efficient" apparently means profitable when things go well and someone else's problem when they don't. Clear examples are the Covid 19 pandemic and the economic crisis it unchained. In Colombia, when the airline Avianca went bankrupt in 2020, the government stepped in with about $370 million in public credit, roughly a fifth of the airline's $2 billion rescue package, while private lenders covered the rest. But the bigger story was in the pandemic payroll support given to businesses across the country: researchers later found that half the workers covered by it worked not at small struggling businesses, but at companies owned by Colombia's richest families. That included hotel and media businesses owned by Sarmiento Angulo, snack and publishing brands owned by Gilinski, a soft drink and broadcasting group owned by Ardila Lülle, and television and cinema chains owned by Santo Domingo. One study found that Colombia gave nearly half of all its pandemic business aid to large companies, more than any other country studied in South America.

Germany told a similar story, just bigger. The airline Lufthansa received a nine billion euro rescue in 2020, and in exchange, the German state became a 20% owner of the company. The tour company TUI received more than four billion euros across several rounds of aid. In both countries, the same pattern repeated: when the market failed, the state stepped in to cover the losses. When the companies recovered, the profits went quietly back to private shareholders, not to the public that had carried the risk.

The lesson from Lufthansa and Avianca is really the same one from the start of this chapter: whoever controls the means of survival controls the people who depend on it. That question is about to repeat itself in a new form. As AI and automation replace more paid labor, the danger isn't liberation, it's deeper concentration, wealth and control pooling upward into whoever owns the machines. A universal basic income, funded through taxation or public enterprise, is one serious answer on the table. Without something like it, the future doesn't flatten inequality between men and women, it just makes everyone equally dependent on whoever owns the technology.

"What to Expect When You Are Expecting Exploitation": On Motherhood

Motherhood gets treated like a private choice, but women are the ones who pay for it, alone. The logic works like this, and it keeps repeating itself: employers think a woman might leave her job once she has children, so they pay her less from the start. Because she's paid less, it "makes sense" that she, not her partner, is the one who quits when a child comes. Discrimination creates itself and then calls itself natural. The market will never fix this on its own, there's no profit in fixing it, so the state has to.
It helps to be clear here: sex is biology. Gender is the story society tells about that biology. Gender discrimination happens exactly at the point where a biological difference turns into a social ranking: man is productive and independent; woman is caring, self-sacrificing, and economically second. That ranking isn't natural. People built it, and people keep it going.

Socialist feminists were saying this over a hundred years ago. In 1897, the German feminist Lily Braun proposed state-funded maternity insurance. Her point was simple: having a child shouldn't mean falling into poverty or losing your job. This wasn't a small issue. Industrial workers at the time worked 60 to 65 hours a week with no maternity leave at all, and maternal and infant death rates showed it. Capitalist economies needed children, future workers, future taxpayers, but made individual women carry the entire cost of having them. The Second International, the alliance of socialist and labor parties that pushed for the eight-hour workday and basic worker protections, demanded tax-funded support for mothers as a normal part of their program. A lot of what we now think of as "normal", paid leave, labor protections, social insurance, started out as a socialist demand, not something given freely.

Where these ideas were actually put into practice, the results were real. Sweden guaranteed 180 days of job-protected leave at 80% of salary by 1963. Bulgaria gave free university education to students who completed national service, so a woman could study and raise a child at the same time instead of choosing between them. East Germany went even further, building housing for mothers and children at universities, so students could raise a baby and keep studying at the same time. By 1989, about a third of births in East Germany happened outside marriage, far more than in the West, and importantly, that did not mean poverty, because childcare and housing support didn't depend on having a husband. That's the important part: a woman shouldn't need to stay in a relationship just to have a place to live.

None of this was simple or purely good. The Soviet Union legalized abortion on demand in 1920, the first country in Europe to do so, only to take much of that back under Stalin in 1936, for reasons tied to growing the population. Across socialist countries, childbearing was often controlled by the state, sometimes in ways that helped women, sometimes in ways that controlled them. But some of these states also pushed, as early as the 1950s in East Germany and Czechoslovakia, for fathers to actually share housework and childcare, recognizing decades before it became a common feminist point that equality can't exist if women are still doing two full jobs, one paid, one not.

When the Soviet bloc collapsed, privatization tore this system down fast. Childcare centers closed, unemployment went up, and the cost of raising children went quietly back onto individual families. Birth rates in East Germany fell sharply after reunification, not because women stopped wanting children, but because the conditions that made having children manageable disappeared. And in an interesting twist, East German women then changed things in the West: when they moved there after 1989, they expected something West German women had never had, that the state, not just the mother, should help carry the weight of raising a child. They pushed for daycare and kindergartens because they had never lived without them.

This is also why maternity leave can't be left up to individual companies to decide on their own. No company wants to be known for offering the most generous parental leave, because it just attracts the workers most likely to use it, and that looks like an extra cost to the company. But when every employer is legally required to offer the same protections, and the state shares the cost, no woman gets punished for being pregnant at the wrong company. Paid leave, free childcare, job protection, these were never extra comforts. They were tools built specifically to take away men's control over women's work, bodies, and survival. Much of today's resistance to these policies is, underneath, really just resistance to losing that control.


Sunday, September 20, 2026

Why women have better sex under socialism - Part 1

This is a review and analysis of the book "Why women have better sex under socialism" to illustrate how economic independence shapes relationships and how capitalism profits from lack of love, affection and connection. 

Jena, Sept. 2026


Cover of Why Women Have Better Sex Under Socialism by Kristen R. Ghodsee

When the Wall came down, she was standing right there

Summer of 1990. Kristen Ghodsee is backpacking through a Europe that has just watched one of its founding myths collapse overnight. The Berlin Wall is down and the entire project of the State Socialism of the Eastern Bloc dissolved, but what follows isn't the parade of freedom everyone promised, it's chaos, uncertainty, entire economies dissolving under people's feet. She doesn't look away. She goes deeper: Bulgaria, East Germany, years of fieldwork asking the question almost nobody else was asking, what actually happens to women when a system like this falls apart? Not to GDP. Not to geopolitics. To women, specifically  their jobs, their childcare, their marriages, their bodies, the love inside their relationships. That question followed her through the Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research in Rostock and the Imre Kertész Kolleg in Jena, both in Eastern Germany, and it's the question this whole book is built to answer.


Two words nobody wants to put in the same sentence: democratic and socialism

Before we even open to chapter one, there's something worth noticing: the word socialism has been welded to its worst moments of the 20th century, the authoritarian systems of Eastern Europe, until the word alone triggers images of control, repression, food rationing, nothing else. That link isn't accidental, and it isn't fair. Two very different things have been merged into one.

On one side, there's state socialism: the Soviet Union, Eastern Europe, one party in charge, elections that weren't really free, almost no room for disagreement. Power moved from the top down, imposed on people rather than chosen by them. On the other side, there's democratic socialism which seeks to overcome capitalism through democratic means, advocating for stronger public ownership, greater social control over the economy, and cooperative forms of organization, accepting capitalism but trying to regulate it and make it fairer through welfare protections and redistribution. Democratic socialism has the same underlying goals as state socialism but reached through free elections, real political competition, and protected civil rights. Power here depends on people choosing it, not on force. For this reason, democratic socialism must be separated from its historical baggage, because confusing these two is exactly why so much of the modern criticism of socialism misses its target: people picture  secret police and food scarcity when what's actually on the table is closer to what built the public healthcare system, paid vacation and parental leave, and balanced working times in the contemporary society.

Many of the protections we now take for granted: public healthcare, paid parental leave, labor rights, were won through socialist or social-democratic movements, not despite them. After World War II, British voters elected a majority democratic-socialist government under Clement Attlee, and that government built the National Health Service and much of the modern welfare state, the same system people in Britain still argue about protecting today. Or look at Bulgaria: one of the poorest countries in the European Union, and yet a poor person there often still enjoys stronger social protections than a poor person in the United States.

Yet today neoliberal ideology dominates mainstream political thinking, teaching people to see the market as natural and alternatives as dangerous and irrealizable. Under that belief of the “private as efficient and less corrupt”, austerity policies cut public services while wealth keeps piling up at the top. Women feel it first, because they are expected to take care for the children, the elder and the sick when public health systems weaken or simply don’t exist. It's usually women who quietly absorb the consequences of failed support social nets.

None of this exhaustion happens by accident. The people who benefit from things staying as they are have every reason to want the rest of us tired, cynical, and disconnected from politics, a hopeless population rarely demands anything. So the point isn't nostalgia for a socialism of the past. It's using socialism as a language again, a set of tools for imagining a future that could actually be fairer.

One more thing worth noticing before moving forward: capitalism rarely gets the same scrutiny, even though it reaches into the most private corners of our lives. It sells sexuality through advertising, television, the beauty industry, dating apps, constantly whispering that we're not attractive enough, successful enough, wanted enough, unless we keep buying some bullshit to fix it. Love, desire, self-worth, all turned into products for sale. However, once we notice how the market prices our bodies, our relationships, our emotions, we can start pushing back against that logic, and take back a sense of worth and human dignity that can’t be sold or measured by profit. 


Introduction: "You Might Be Suffering From Capitalism"

The central idea is simple: unregulated capitalism is bad for women, and some socialist ideas can make women's lives materially better. The system works well for a small group of women at the top, but for most women, reality looks different; lower wages, less security, less access to healthcare, more dependence on men, less control over their own bodies and futures. Women are usually the last to be hired and the first to be fired, and when budget cuts hit education, healthcare, pensions, or childcare, it's mothers, daughters, sisters, and wives who quietly absorb the unpaid work of caring for the young, the sick, and the elderly.

Economic dependence reaches into intimacy too. Women with less economic freedom often have less control over their own reproduction, more pressure to stay in unhealthy relationships, and fewer real choices about motherhood. By contrast, where the state provides childcare, paid leave, healthcare, and labor protections, something shifts: women get to choose a relationship because they want it, not because they need it to survive.

That shift was one of the real, material achievements of state socialism. In the Soviet Union, East Germany, and much of Eastern Europe, bringing women fully into paid work became an actual political goal — not a slogan. Women entered medicine, engineering, and science, professions that had mostly excluded them, backed by public childcare, shared cafeterias, laundry services, paid leave, and legal rights to work, own property, and live independently. This independence was real enough to be seen as a threat elsewhere: for years after World War II, a woman earning her own wage in the United States or West Germany was treated almost like a sign of communist danger, and that fear helped fuel political reactions. It was also real enough to force capitalist countries to compete, women's rights improved partly because capitalism had a rival to keep up with. None of this makes those socialist systems fair or free of serious problems; many were deeply authoritarian. But it does break a common myth, that these societies were defined only by hunger, repression, and surveillance. They lasted for decades and produced real gains beyond that image.

Once the Soviet Union collapsed, the pressure to compete disappeared. Free-market policy expanded fast, protections shrank, and selling off public services was sold as common sense — the state was called inefficient, until private companies failed and had to be rescued with public money anyway. Clear examples are everywhere: in 2008, the US government poured close to $180 billion into the insurance giant AIG and roughly $80 billion into General Motors and Chrysler to stop them from collapsing, while the UK nationalized most of Royal Bank of Scotland almost overnight. Argentina went through its own version of this in 2001–2002: after the peso's fixed exchange rate collapsed and the economy defaulted, the state forced a currency conversion that left banks holding huge losses, and then compensated them with billions of dollars in public bonds, quietly transferring private losses onto public debt. In every case, the pattern repeats: markets fail, and the public ends up paying for a system that never shared its profits the same way.

Women across Eastern Europe who had once worked as professionals were pushed into unstable, low-paid work: cleaning, domestic labor, or the international sex trade. At the same time, nationalist governments opposed to abortion rights told women to return to traditional roles, restricting abortion while asking them to have more children for the nation. The irony is hard to miss: women who once had more independence are now told that this new insecurity is what freedom looks like.

Criticizing capitalism today still gets dismissed with a single word, "communism", as if history only ever offered two choices. But believing capitalism is the final, fairest system humanly possible is just as naive as believing kings once ruled by divine right. No socialist experiment was ever allowed to grow without outside pressure or open conflict from rival powers, so other paths were never fully explored. The real question isn't whether past socialism was perfect. It wasn't. The real question is why imagining any alternative to today's inequality still feels so hard.

And here's the part worth keeping in mind: in more equal societies, where women depend less on a man's money, a certain kind of male power, built on money, status, and control,  loses its grip. That discomfort reveals how much of what is called romance is often just hierarchy disguised as nature.